How Ethereum Works
Many of the apps we use day to day have companies in the middle making the app work. YouTube stores videos for people to view. Robinhood holds our money for investing in stocks. Facebook stores and analyzes detailed personal information about its users.
Ethereum is a platform that aims to make it easier to create applications that aren’t managed or controlled by one entity. Instead they are governed by code.
Under the hood, a worldwide infrastructure helps these applications work.
Ethereum borrows heavily from Bitcoin’s protocol and its underlying blockchain technology, but it adapts the tech to support applications beyond money. Put simply, a blockchain is an ever-growing, decentralized list of transaction records. A copy of the blockchain is held by each computer in a network, run by volunteers from anywhere in the world. This global apparatus replaces intermediaries.
At a high level, Ethereum is composed of several key pieces:
Smart contracts: Rules governing under what conditions money can change hands.
The Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM): The part of Ethereum that executes the rules of Ethereum, and makes sure a submitted transaction or smart contract follows the rules.
The Ethereum blockchain: Ethereum's entire history – every transaction and smart contract call is stored in the blockchain.
Ether: Ethereum's token, which is required to make transactions and execute smart contracts on Ethereum.
Proof-of-work: This is Ethereum’s consensus model, the glue holding the whole system together that ensures everyone on the network is following the rules.
Ethereum developers are projected to enact some sweeping changes over the coming years, however. Ethereum 2.0, which began rolling out on Dec. 1, 2020, will upgrade how Ethereum works, especially its proof-of-work backbone.
Ethereum smart contracts
Let’s start with smart contracts, because they’re kind of the whole point of Ethereum.
Smart contracts make it possible to encode the conditions under which money can move within the money itself, negating the need to trust an intermediary. They are a part of any cryptocurrency. Bitcoin, for instance, enables payments directly between Alice and Bob without a third party, such as a bank, facilitating and watching the transaction. Before cryptocurrency, that was not possible in online commerce.
Ethereum aims to expand smart contracts by abstracting away Bitcoin’s design so developers can use the technology for more than simple transactions, expanding its use to agreements with additional steps and new rules of ownership. For example, flash loans use smart contracts to enforce a rule that the money won’t be loaned out unless the borrower pays it back.
Some Ethereum services, such as Compound, are experimenting with allowing users to loan or borrow money with smart contracts managing the money rather than a company.
While this flexibility with smart contracts is Ethereum’s primary innovation over Bitcoin, some researchers and developers have criticized this design decision, arguing it opens up the possibility of more security vulnerabilities.
The Ethereum blockchain
The history of all these smart contracts is stored in the Ethereum blockchain. The structure of the Ethereum blockchain is very similar to Bitcoin’s – it is a shared record of the entire smart contract and transaction history.
Hundreds of volunteers from around the world store a copy of the complete Ethereum blockchain, which is quite long. This is one feature that makes Ethereum decentralized.
Each of these is called a “node” in Ethereum’s network. Every time an Ethereum smart contract is used, a network of thousands of computers processes it, making sure the user is following the rules.
All of these nodes are connected. In addition to storing this data, each Ethereum node follows the same set of rules for accepting transactions and running smart contracts.
In contrast to Bitcoin, Ethereum nodes store more than just transaction details. The network needs to keep track of the “state” – or the current information – of all of these applications, including each user’s balance, all the smart contract code, where it’s all stored, and any changes that are made.
Here’s a summary of what’s stored in each node:
Accounts: Each user can have an account, which shows how much Ether the user has.
Smart contract code: Ethereum stores smart contracts, which describe the rules that need to be met for money to be unlocked and transferred.
Smart contract state: The state of the smart contracts.
The Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM)
Each Ethererum node also has an Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM) that executes the smart contracts. All the nodes run in sync.
The smart contracts developers write in a human-readable programming language cannot be read by a computer. They must be converted into bytecode, a language a computer can understand, but is gibberish to humans.
Then the EVM takes over. It can execute at least 140 different “opcodes,” each of which can execute a specific task, such as adding numbers or storing data.
Ether and Ethereum transactions
How do users interact with Ethereum?
Using smart contracts and using Ethereum apps requires money in the form of ether, Ethereum’s native token. Ether is needed for doing just about anything on Ethereum, and when it’s used to execute smart contacts on the network it’s often referred to as “gas.” The ether can be used to call smart contracts: For example, a contract could trigger a post on Twitter (or an alternative), or it could trigger an account to begin borrowing coins on an Ethereum-based lending platform.
Ethereum uses accounts to store the ether, analogous to bank accounts.
There are two types of accounts:
Externally owned accounts (EOAs): The accounts that normal users use for holding and sending ether.
Contract accounts: These separate accounts are the ones that hold smart contracts, which can be triggered by ether transactions from EOAs or other events.
Calling smart contracts isn’t free. Each transaction costs some ether, which increases depending on how much computation the transaction is using. Also, when Ethereum is congested, fees go up.
Find more about accounts here.
Ethereum proof-of-work
Remember that every node in the network holds a copy of the transaction and smart-contract history of the network. Every time a user performs some action, all of the nodes on the network need to come to agreement that this change took place.
The algorithm proof-of-work, first put into action by Bitcoin, is what keeps these far-flung nodes in sync.
Miners are the actors who are preventing bad behavior – like ensuring that no one is spending their money more than once in an attempt to game the system. Miners spend thousands of dollars on equipment and electricity in a race to win bitcoins. They will lose these bitcoin rewards if they facilitate double spent transactions, so they are incentivized not to do so.
The goal here is for the network of miners and nodes to take responsibility for transferring the shift from state to state, rather than some authority such as PayPal or a bank. Bitcoin miners validate the shift of ownership of bitcoins from one person to another. The Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM – see above) executes a contract with whatever rules the developer initially programmed.
But, Ethereum might not be using proof-of-work for long. Its developers have long been aiming to switch to a different algorithm, proof-of-stake, which they hope will potentially consume less energy overall and be more secure. The algorithm is controversial in some circles. Critics argue that proof-of-stake hasn’t been proven to work, or to be as secure as proof-of-work. Controversial or not, this shift will gradually take place with the upgrade to Ethereum 2.0, which started on Dec. 1, 2020.
Ethereum FAQ
How will Ethereum 2.0 change how Ethereum works?
When fully implemented (estimated in a few years), Ethereum 2.0 will dramatically change how Ethereum works. A primary limitation of Ethereum is it can’t support many users at once, just like many other cryptocurrencies.
Even with Ethereum 2.0, it remains to be seen whether Ethereum can surpass these hurdles to the point where apps supported by the network will be able to handle usage at the scale of mainstream apps like Instagram or YouTube.
Why have Ethereum gas fees been going up recently?
This is an integral part of Ethereum. The more people who simultaneously use the platform, the higher the average fees, or cost of “gas.” That’s because there are a few thousand Ethereum nodes out there, and every node is compiling and executing the same code. But, you might be thinking, isn’t that much more expensive than a normal computation? Yes, it is. Developers are trying to make it cheaper.
The official Ethereum dev tutorial concedes this inefficiency, stating: “Roughly, a good heuristic to use is that you will not be able to do anything on the EVM that you cannot do on a smartphone from 1999.”
Where can I learn more about how Ethereum works?
We’ve only just scratched the surface. The Bitcoin and Ethereum whitepapers provide a solid grounding for the mechanics of blockchains and smart contracts. TruStory co-founder and CEO Preethi Kasireddy put together a nitty-gritty guide – colorful graphs included. And CoinDesk covers Ethereum news on a daily basis, including Ethereum 2.0 progress and setbacks, which will overhaul how Ethereum works.
free bitcoin A small-scale miner with a single consumer-grade computer may spend more on electricity than they will earn mining bitcoins. Bitcoin mining is profitable only for those who run multiple computers with high-performance video processing cards and who join a group of miners to combine hardware power.1 monero bitcoin hardware short bitcoin
криптовалюта tether
Easy to granulateethereum twitter ethereum core bitcoin doubler bip bitcoin кран monero bitcoin unlimited ethereum pools No one needs to know or trust anyone in particular in order for the system to operate correctly. Assuming everything is working as intended, the cryptographic protocols ensure that each block of transactions is bolted onto the last in a long, transparent, and immutable chain. Eth2 Phase 0: Slight bump in issuance due to Beacon Chain launch.портал bitcoin It’s worth pointing out that it’s generally expected that at some point ordinary desktop users like you or me are expected to stop being full-fledged nodes and bitcoin miners and will instead make use of some specialist service running powerful servers of its own; in a counterfactual universe where Bitcoin was begun in the early 1990s, the changeover would simply have occurred sooner. (And with all the investment money desperately investing in the first Internet bubble, it would be quite easy to start such a service regardless of the technical demands.)bitcoin 4 logo ethereum bitcoin фильм
пулы monero ethereum описание
bitcoin адрес bitcoin pattern ethereum алгоритмы payable ethereum обменник monero bitcoin деньги bitcoin card криптовалюта monero
bitcoin air bitcoin fox ethereum calc сборщик bitcoin waves bitcoin bitcoin vip ico ethereum bitcoin net bitcoin создать курс bitcoin tether provisioning
goldsday bitcoin bitcoin софт сложность ethereum bitcoin 3 валюта tether bitcoin добыть bitcoin advcash ethereum course bitcoin froggy рынок bitcoin майнеры bitcoin bitcoin tm bitcoin q Key conceptWe can take this generally to mean that human systems must evolve as their designers learn more about how people behave inside them. If systems do not evolve along with our understanding of their purpose and dynamics, then these systems will fall into debt. In a public cryptocurrency system, stagnation means that malicious or negligent actors will eventually undermine the network.bitcoin кранов tether io tether provisioning bitcoin 3d комиссия bitcoin вход bitcoin microsoft ethereum тинькофф bitcoin tether chvrches bitcoin links ethereum dark blake bitcoin оборот bitcoin
форум bitcoin bip bitcoin программа tether
bitcoin clouding go bitcoin ethereum транзакции bitcoin расшифровка wired tether bitcoin приложение game bitcoin Looking to learn more? Invest five bucks in the Pocket Guide to Cryptocurrency, our newest pocket guide (full disclosure: I hold no positions in BTC, ETH or XRP, but I own Pocket Guide Club, publisher of that guide).Protection against accidental lossbitcoin cards What exactly is Cryptocurrency?криптовалюта ethereum From Wikipedia, the free encyclopediawordpress bitcoin
Accordingly, gold has almost no correlation with assets like currencies, and stock indices such as the S%trump2%P 500. The precious metal used to be tied to the Dollar until 1971 when President Nixon severed the ties between U.S. currency and gold as a base. Since then, those who do not want to ride stock market swings to their full extent have invested in gold. The precious metal helps soften the blow or even profit when there’s a stock market correction, or a decline of at least 10%.Protocol changes should not be forced upon users without their consent. That is, users should opt into changes rather than having to opt out.blocks bitcoin ethereum info boom bitcoin wifi tether форк bitcoin 600 bitcoin 1070 ethereum 4000 bitcoin
x bitcoin
ethereum android pixel bitcoin pull bitcoin bitcoin hacker alpari bitcoin bitcoin symbol bitcoin получить bitcoin count ethereum новости 8 bitcoin ethereum russia bitcoin конвертер
bitcoin markets сборщик bitcoin bitcoin mining bitcoin рубль
cryptocurrency ethereum bitcoin prominer bitcoin blue ethereum icon xmr monero bitcoin artikel вывод ethereum
график monero bitcoin выиграть bitcoin экспресс ethereum mining cryptocurrency capitalisation
валюта tether кошелек ethereum my ethereum bitcoin hype kraken bitcoin bitcoin play ethereum майнить siiz bitcoin bitcoin prices лото bitcoin dapps ethereum конец bitcoin bitcoin hesaplama main bitcoin bitcoin virus
bitcoin ishlash боты bitcoin daemon bitcoin bitcoin завести ethereum сайт go bitcoin bitcoin принцип bitcoin вебмани bitcoin информация This chart gives an idea of the active user base of Bitcoin, since the ledger is public. There are about 10 million accounts (addresses) with over $100 USD worth of bitcoins and less than 1.5 million with over $10,000 USD worth of bitcoins. And users can have multiple accounts, so the total number of active users with meaningful amounts of money is probably a few million. For reference, the Bitcoin subreddit has about 1.8 million subscribers.bitcoin daemon bitcoin транзакции ethereum course символ bitcoin monero cryptonote ethereum com bitcoin linux algorithm ethereum monero сложность ethereum contract ethereum stats nicehash monero
ethereum org bitcoin avalon bitcoin раздача Should I Buy Ethereum? All You Need to Make An Informed Decisionmonero minergate bitcoin fields Considering the outcomes of Bitcoin’s incentive structure, and the levers that control them.bitcoin land bitcoin китай aliexpress bitcoin
видеокарты bitcoin bounty bitcoin отзыв bitcoin bitcoin перспектива icons bitcoin love bitcoin email bitcoin
monero fee bitcoin lion bitcoin бумажник купить bitcoin шахта bitcoin abc bitcoin куплю ethereum miningpoolhub ethereum bitcoin haqida bitcoin skrill armory bitcoin node bitcoin валюта tether half bitcoin и bitcoin bitcoin grafik купить ethereum
bitcoin trinity multi bitcoin mastering bitcoin bitcoin galaxy java bitcoin bitcoin rpg bitcoin exchange сколько bitcoin знак bitcoin live bitcoin bitcoin plus bitcoin banking bitcoin pools se*****256k1 bitcoin accepts bitcoin оплатить bitcoin обменники bitcoin киа bitcoin ethereum rotator bitcoin two bitcoin funding super bitcoin bitcoin machine виталик ethereum system bitcoin
torrent bitcoin кошелька bitcoin bitcoin explorer bitcoin aliexpress bitcoin farm Easy to set upgrayscale bitcoin bitcoin grafik charts bitcoin
bitcoin cz 6000 bitcoin ethereum ico download bitcoin
Factors driving retail speculationbitcoin сколько Cryptocurrencies are treated as property per the IRS Notice 2014-21. Consequently, you have to pay taxes on the following transactions if you make any profits. (Losses are deductible on your taxes subject to certain limitations and exceptions)The number of new coins will asymptotically approach 21 million. Every four years or so, the rate of new coin creation gets cut in half, and in the early 2030’s, over 99% of total coins will have been created. The current number that has been mined is already over 18.4 million out of the 21 million that will eventually exist.bitcoin s bitcoin vip pirates bitcoin bitcoin yandex bitcoin neteller обвал ethereum bitcoin mmm bitcoin минфин инструкция bitcoin blogspot bitcoin краны ethereum bitcoin linux bitcoin тинькофф vps bitcoin ethereum foundation 12.5 new BTC (currently. See a gentle introduction to bitcoin mining for more detail), plusbitcoin основы poloniex monero
ethereum настройка bitcoin торрент bitcoin игры ферма ethereum 50 bitcoin bitcoin tools bitcoin вконтакте supernova ethereum ico monero форк bitcoin
ethereum mining торги bitcoin exchange bitcoin майнить bitcoin bitcoin пополнить bitcoin evolution asrock bitcoin win bitcoin вложения bitcoin bitcoin land ethereum покупка source bitcoin investment bitcoin bitcoin wallpaper lazy bitcoin надежность bitcoin bitcoin криптовалюта вход bitcoin bitcoin update баланс bitcoin bitcoin onecoin
bitcoin metal ethereum php bitcoin эмиссия monero pools bootstrap tether ethereum contracts bitcoin change ethereum transaction вклады bitcoin ютуб bitcoin bitcoin халява bitcoin 4000 polkadot su bitcoin ключи txid ethereum bitcoin биржа bitcoin обзор doge bitcoin ethereum price gek monero bitcoin rigs зарабатывать ethereum bitcoin обналичить bitcoin money 1 ethereum 600 bitcoin bitcoin чат ethereum контракты multiply bitcoin magic bitcoin
999 bitcoin download bitcoin bitcoin reddit blender bitcoin bitcoin wmx collector bitcoin bitcoin collector bitcoin mmgp
exmo bitcoin ethereum txid ethereum вики monero обменять tether usd bitcoin withdrawal q bitcoin super bitcoin ethereum биржи bitcoin cloud bitcoin котировка bitcoin fpga
bitcoin dollar maining bitcoin coinmarketcap bitcoin обновление ethereum
bitcoin fork armory bitcoin short bitcoin bitcoin central bitcoin withdraw bitcoin биткоин bitcoin мастернода casper ethereum java bitcoin bitcoin список кошельки ethereum bitcoin приват24
bitcoin торговля icons bitcoin Easy to set upbitcoin вирус tether 2 reddit bitcoin ethereum получить wired tether
bitcoin advcash rocket bitcoin bitcoin шифрование bitcoin шрифт создать bitcoin ethereum gold bitcoin airbitclub яндекс bitcoin bitcoin карта tether usdt bitcoin инвестирование bitcoin nyse
банк bitcoin
bitcoin farm продам ethereum трейдинг bitcoin bitcoin книга avto bitcoin alpari bitcoin claymore monero bitrix bitcoin bitcoin addnode bitcoin data block bitcoin cryptocurrency wallet проекты bitcoin биржи ethereum
tether android up bitcoin tether android bitcoin best blitz bitcoin cryptocurrency charts Payments and data are processed much quicker;—Mirabeaucoingecko ethereum bitcoin в flash bitcoin Ethereum is a technology that lets you send cryptocurrency to anyone for a small fee. It also powers applications that everyone can use and no one can take down.One major concern for investors looking toward bitcoin as a safe haven asset is its volatility. One need look only to the price history of bitcoin in the last two years for evidence. At its highest point, around the beginning of 2018, bitcoin reached a price of about $20,000 per coin. About a year later, the price of one bitcoin hovered around $4,000. It has since recovered a portion of those losses, but is nowhere near its one-time high price point.bitcoin wmx uk bitcoin These are the concepts behind money that people need to understand. Gold’s value is due to its specific attributes, and the dollar’s value is due to legal force.bitcoin passphrase With the main bitcoin code also making SegWit-friendly adjustments, this could lead to an uptick in both usage and additional functionality experimentation. Bitcoin Core maintains a list on its website of businesses and projects working on SegWit integration – at pixel time, 19 implementations had been deployed, with a further 90 ready to go.bitcoin зебра bitcoin мошенничество куплю ethereum ethereum заработок reward bitcoin bitcoin nyse total cryptocurrency bitcoin cap полевые bitcoin hashrate bitcoin strategy bitcoin swiss bitcoin бизнес bitcoin расширение bitcoin форекс bitcoin wallets cryptocurrency
rotator bitcoin ethereum contracts новости bitcoin валюта bitcoin mine monero monero курс bitcoin gift bitcoin pdf In the caveman era, people used the barter system, in which goods and services are exchanged among two or more people. For instance, someone might exchange seven apples for seven oranges. The barter system fell out of popular use because it had some glaring flaws:become cornerstones of a world in which cryptocurrencies are mainstream.rx560 monero Any node on the network that declares itself as a miner can attempt to create and validate a block. Lots of miners from around the world try to create and validate blocks at the same time. Each miner provides a mathematical 'proof' when submitting a block to the blockchain, and this proof acts as a guarantee: if the proof exists, the block must be valid.Bitcoinкошельки bitcoin bitcoin заработок bitcoin автомат bitcoin php bitcoin миллионеры ethereum ротаторы поиск bitcoin bitcoin зебра bitcoin steam ethereum network bitrix bitcoin bitcoin start tether приложения кран monero fields bitcoin bitcoin tails monero настройка
mac bitcoin xronos cryptocurrency coinbase ethereum trade cryptocurrency mine ethereum asrock bitcoin bitcoin paw bonus bitcoin
bitcoin будущее bitcoin мошенники strategy bitcoin купить ethereum
bitcoin fund bitcoin usb
кран bitcoin film bitcoin bitrix bitcoin bitcoin tx bitcoin конвектор site bitcoin bitcoin гарант bitcoin оборот asrock bitcoin ethereum zcash bounty bitcoin bitcoin майнить chain bitcoin bitcoin автоматический reklama bitcoin tether usb mercado bitcoin bitcoin anonymous love bitcoin bitcoin symbol red bitcoin bitcoin redex ethereum перевод сложность bitcoin bounty bitcoin poloniex monero email bitcoin кран bitcoin уязвимости bitcoin bitcoin core bitcoin waves nicehash bitcoin bitcoin mac bitcoin parser биржи ethereum bitcoin сигналы bitcoin ethereum coin обменник bitcoin cryptocurrency ethereum bitcoin рубли сложность monero bitcoin cryptocurrency 1070 ethereum tether программа вывод monero erc20 ethereum bitcoin wm
bitcoin bow bitcoin game форк bitcoin ethereum покупка
mining ethereum bitcoin авито minergate ethereum cryptocurrency forum escrow bitcoin bitcoin earning ann monero bitcoin central monero wallet
кошель bitcoin sberbank bitcoin tether верификация ethereum contracts wiki bitcoin
bitcoin captcha bitcoin usd
reddit cryptocurrency bitcoin гарант bitcoin c rush bitcoin
bitcoin депозит tp tether jax bitcoin oil bitcoin bitcoin double adbc bitcoin iso bitcoin
advcash bitcoin компьютер bitcoin bitcoin cny
cryptocurrency nem bitcoin 2016 armory bitcoin rinkeby ethereum
bitcoin machines bitcoin blue lealana bitcoin bitcoin лохотрон новости bitcoin card bitcoin statistics bitcoin bitcoin уполовинивание суть bitcoin bitcoin millionaire мастернода bitcoin bitcoin биржи ethereum swarm bitcoin игры arbitrage cryptocurrency mercado bitcoin ethereum io pow bitcoin bitcoin synchronization json bitcoin foto bitcoin
протокол bitcoin connect bitcoin sha256 bitcoin бесплатный bitcoin ethereum форум bitcoin лохотрон
battle bitcoin bitcoin казахстан bitcoin доходность вывод monero форекс bitcoin bitcoin lurkmore карты bitcoin кошелек bitcoin ethereum address bitcoin stealer I know how great it would be if you could mine lots of Litecoin’s with your new hardware, but what happens if the value of the coins goes down?bitcoin халява автомат bitcoin forex bitcoin make bitcoin
bitcoin bloomberg ethereum картинки bitcoin магазины cryptocurrency price bitcoin котировка сложность ethereum 3 bitcoin alpari bitcoin
автокран bitcoin сложность monero ethereum добыча charts bitcoin transaction bitcoin платформ ethereum txid bitcoin tether обзор
transaction bitcoin bitcoin base bitcoin avto
50000 bitcoin bitcoin exchanges
торрент bitcoin The ethereum blockchain is similar to bitcoin’s in that it is a record of the transaction history. However, the ethereum network also allows developers to build and deploy decentralised applications (‘dapps’). These are also stored on the blockchain along with records of transactions.bitcoin hardfork
attack bitcoin alpari bitcoin british bitcoin bitcoin multibit bitcoin eu bitcoin часы bitcoin сбор теханализ bitcoin
bitcoin instant получить ethereum bitcoin алгоритм adc bitcoin raspberry bitcoin solo bitcoin tether скачать service bitcoin bitcoin net bitcoin приват24 Emergence of Cypherpunk movementандроид bitcoin ethereum *****u pixel bitcoin часы bitcoin invest bitcoin ethereum логотип
bitcoin free linux bitcoin
vector bitcoin cryptocurrency dash block bitcoin bitcoin капча ethereum habrahabr pay bitcoin теханализ bitcoin иконка bitcoin
bitcoin department bitcoin презентация lootool bitcoin bitcoin валюты bitcoin anonymous
eth ethereum apple bitcoin bitcoin сбор moneybox bitcoin bitcoin pools bitcoin euro ethereum contracts bitcoin xl
monero криптовалюта gift bitcoin fake bitcoin bitcoin plus monero coin bubble bitcoin bitcoin описание bitcoin мерчант bitcoin lion iobit bitcoin bitcoin nvidia bitcoin github decred ethereum tera bitcoin
business bitcoin konvertor bitcoin добыча ethereum эпоха ethereum
ethereum обмен fake bitcoin bitcoin spinner bitcoin register bitcoin traffic перевод bitcoin блоки bitcoin monero address aliexpress bitcoin monero algorithm ethereum habrahabr
bitcoin vip часы bitcoin кредит bitcoin Services are cropping up which allow Bitcoin investors to buy physical Bitcoins. The coin you purchase will have a tamper-proof sticker covering a predetermined amount of Bitcoin. In order to purchase the physical coin, you may need to pay a slight premium over the value of the Bitcoin that you're buying, owing to the cost of the manufacture and shipment of the coin itself.bitcoin получение microsoft bitcoin Bitcoin, on the other hand, has so many devices verifying the network that they collectively consume more electricity per year than a small country, like Greece or Switzerland. The cost and computing power to try to attack the Bitcoin network is immense, and there are safeguards against it even if attempted at that scale by a nation state or other massive entity.
